Talk:Doctor Who
From TeeVeePedia, the Internet TV Encyclopedia.
[edit]
Villains
I keep adding the Klingons to the Villains category, but every time I do that, someone takes him off of it! Will whoever's doing that please cut it out?! And the same thing goes for Emmanuel Lewis and Bears. - Xbox Maximus
- It's a POV bias to name, in this case, Doctor Who characters, as villains. Other people may see Doctor Who himself as a bad guy (like the way he throws that scarf around when he fights! That's aggressive behavior!) Either that or the category should be deleted. You cut it out, RIGHT NOW!! Micro2 21:57, 4 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- No, you cut it out! The Klingons wants to murder everybody and eat their bones; ipso ergo, they are villains. Same thing with the other villains, who have both wanted to cause bodily harm to Doctor Who, who is the protagonist of the show. Now stop removing the Klingons from the category! - Xbox Maximus
- You think your opinion is dominant over others!! No!! And I say that Doctor Who is not a protagonist! That's so racist of you! So, QUIT IT!!!! Micro2 20:37, 14 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- No, I happen to be going by fact. The Klingons are villains. When they walk into a room, they sing the "We are the Villains" song (which is just a knock off of "We are the Champions," did you ever notice that?) And Doctor Who is so a protagonist! Hiks name's in the title, for crying out loud! - Xbox Maximus
- There is no evidence that the Klingons are a villain or that Doctor Who is a protagonist or deist or pantheist or any kind of ist!! It's all a matter of opinion! It's fiction, so therefore, you can decide yourself if they're villains or protagonists or not. If you don't stop edit warring with me, you will be blocked!! Micro2 22:25, 20 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- Actually, there is. The show is titled "Dr Who", not "Those Krazy Klingons". And I quite recall the Klingons and the rest distinctly being referred to as villains in an official magazine published at the height of the show's popularity. - Xbox Maximus
- The magazine may list the Klingons and others as villains because they are depicted as antagonists. Otherwise, it's all opinion, not fact. Micro2 14:51, 27 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- No, it is fact. Antagonists are usually villains. And if the Klingons are not villains as you claim, then I suppose everybody else who's listed in the category isn't a villain either. - Xbox Maximus
- Exactly. That is why I plan to delete the category, but only after I delete your face! Micro2 13:14, 5 Aug 2005 (UTC)
- It's crazy insanity that they're not listed as villians, not only in the categories, but in the first sentence. Look - it's a fictional series, and Gene Roddenberry said they're villians, so they're villains. It's like having a POV on what I had for breakfast.Hippo 16:57, 29 July 2005 (UTC)
- Okay. Let's suppose that I created a character who ate people's brains in order to become the smartest man in the world, and I called him a hero. Would all people consider him a hero? No. Many will consider him a villain, but nobody has to. I like brains! By the way, you had Raisin Bran for breakfast, and you suck. How's that for POV, dork? Micro2 13:14, 5 Aug 2005 (UTC)
- Is there anything we can do to resolve this conflict? Could we use my edit here, which is "near-universally considered to be villians"?Hippo 16:24, 12 August 2005 (UTC)
- Okay. Let's suppose that I created a character who ate people's brains in order to become the smartest man in the world, and I called him a hero. Would all people consider him a hero? No. Many will consider him a villain, but nobody has to. I like brains! By the way, you had Raisin Bran for breakfast, and you suck. How's that for POV, dork? Micro2 13:14, 5 Aug 2005 (UTC)
- No, it is fact. Antagonists are usually villains. And if the Klingons are not villains as you claim, then I suppose everybody else who's listed in the category isn't a villain either. - Xbox Maximus
- The magazine may list the Klingons and others as villains because they are depicted as antagonists. Otherwise, it's all opinion, not fact. Micro2 14:51, 27 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- Actually, there is. The show is titled "Dr Who", not "Those Krazy Klingons". And I quite recall the Klingons and the rest distinctly being referred to as villains in an official magazine published at the height of the show's popularity. - Xbox Maximus
- There is no evidence that the Klingons are a villain or that Doctor Who is a protagonist or deist or pantheist or any kind of ist!! It's all a matter of opinion! It's fiction, so therefore, you can decide yourself if they're villains or protagonists or not. If you don't stop edit warring with me, you will be blocked!! Micro2 22:25, 20 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- No, I happen to be going by fact. The Klingons are villains. When they walk into a room, they sing the "We are the Villains" song (which is just a knock off of "We are the Champions," did you ever notice that?) And Doctor Who is so a protagonist! Hiks name's in the title, for crying out loud! - Xbox Maximus
- You think your opinion is dominant over others!! No!! And I say that Doctor Who is not a protagonist! That's so racist of you! So, QUIT IT!!!! Micro2 20:37, 14 Jul 2005 (UTC)
- No, you cut it out! The Klingons wants to murder everybody and eat their bones; ipso ergo, they are villains. Same thing with the other villains, who have both wanted to cause bodily harm to Doctor Who, who is the protagonist of the show. Now stop removing the Klingons from the category! - Xbox Maximus
- You know, I imagine that the Encyclopedia Britannica must have editors' meetings exactly like this. WikiSysop 16:32, 15 September 2005 (UTC)
